Why Punishing Michael Cheika Won’t Solve the Problem: France within Their Rights to Make All Blacks Tour Decision

news-09102024-090115

This week, we are diving into the recent events surrounding Michael Cheika, France’s proposed law changes, and the ongoing calendar conflicts in the world of rugby. Michael Cheika, the fiery coach at Mattioli Woods Welford Road, has found himself in hot water after a couple of incidents involving the HIA protocols. The issue at hand is not just about Cheika losing his temper but rather the breakdown of the processes in place to ensure player safety.

The confusion and mix-ups surrounding player assessments and return-to-play decisions highlight a larger problem within the system. With head injuries being a major concern in rugby, it is crucial that the protocols are followed correctly and consistently. Censuring individuals like Cheika might not be the solution; instead, a closer look at the HIA processes and how they can be improved is necessary.

On the other side of the Channel, France is making waves with their proposed law changes for the game. From eliminating the 20-minute red card to implementing a 30-second set-piece countdown clock, these changes aim to make the game more efficient and strategic. One particularly intriguing proposal is the idea of limiting substitutions but expanding the pool of players to choose from, adding a new layer of strategy to the game.

Additionally, stopping the clock between tries and restarts is another welcomed change that could streamline the game and eliminate unnecessary delays. While these changes may not be suitable for the amateur level, they could bring an exciting new dimension to professional rugby.

Lastly, the ongoing issue of calendar conflicts and player fatigue continues to plague the sport. France’s decision to potentially send a weakened squad to New Zealand for their tour next June is well within their rights. The overlapping seasons and jam-packed schedules put a strain on players and teams, leading to difficult decisions regarding international tours.

Instead of focusing solely on individual teams’ choices, it is crucial to address the root cause of these conflicts – the ever-expanding rugby calendar. By reevaluating the structure of the season and finding ways to reduce overlap, the sport can ensure the well-being of players and the quality of competition. France’s bold stance may serve as a catalyst for much-needed changes in the sport.

Exit mobile version