Buy a bottle of water a little more expensive then bring it back to the supermarket, empty, for a few cents returned by an automaton? Or improve the sorting of plastic waste, at home and on the street, to increase recycling volumes? The government is relaunching a debate on Monday, January 30, on the possible introduction of deposits for plastic bottles in France.
This initiative had been considered during the vote on the anti-waste law for a circular economy (Agec) in 2020 before being aborted under the strong opposition of local authorities. Food industry, bottling, supermarkets, associations of elected officials, consumers and NGOs, some 70 stakeholders are invited from Monday by the Secretary of State for Ecology Bérangère Couillard, who intends to decide in June.
In countries where it exists, such as Germany, the deposit – ie reimbursement of the container to consumers who return their empty bottles to a collection point – works well and helps to increase recycling rates.
The European targets for the collection rate of plastic bottles are 77% in 2025 and 90% in 2029. However, France’s performance is capped below 60%, because plastic packaging is not collected well enough, or not at all. sorted at all in most street or workplace bins.
“Thanks to the dialogue that will take place over several months, we will be able to make the decision that will best meet our main objectives: to achieve a better bottle collection rate, aim for 100% recycled plastic, develop reuse and fight against wild dumps,” Bérangère Couillard said last week, inviting consultation.
In the government, it is admitted that the imposition of a deposit on plastic bottles, a provision withdrawn in extremis during the vote on the Agec law under pressure from the communities, would have had the effect of reducing the flow of plastic in the bins yellow of household waste sorted for recycling, and to reduce the income of sorting centers run by municipalities. Negotiated between 600 and 700 euros per tonne, PET plastic for recycling has indeed become a godsend for them.
And sorting centers have invested heavily in expensive machines to improve sorting, material by material and package by package. This has finally made it possible, after more than a decade of preparations, to simplify, since January 1, the sorting instructions for almost all French people, opening up the hope of finally increasing recycling volumes. From now on, all packaging whatsoever must be thrown into the yellow bins: all plastics (PET, polystyrene, PVC..), aluminum cans or aerosols, steel cans, and of course, papers and boxes.
But automatons for collecting bottles are multiplying everywhere, we recognize at the ministry, kinds of “wild depots […] that will have to be organized”. Because everyone has an interest in recovering this plastic: plastics manufacturers must include a minimum percentage of recycled plastic in their products to meet their European climate obligations; the communities derive an income from it.
In some cities, these “wild” deposits have “led parallel networks to carry out looting of yellow bins to supply the automatons”, we note from the same source.
The deposit has advantages. In the countries where it exists, it significantly increases the plastic collection rate, argue the professionals. It is also of interest to distributors, because the automatons attract certain customers who had deserted the supermarkets since the Covid period, notes an observer.
On the other hand, “the deposit monetizes a sorting gesture, which risks being completely devalued”, criticizes Nicolas Garnier of the Amorce association, which brings together the communities organizing the collection and sorting of waste. “It risks reducing the mobilization of the French to sort their waste at home. »
The deposit also results in an additional food cost for the improvident who forget to bring back their empty bottles, since these will not recover the “deposit” paid for the purchase of their bottle.